Non-Alcoholic Margarita Case of 24 vs Variety Pack: Which to Buy?
By Lyres | Published: 2026-10-13
Category: Comparisons
Compare Lyre's Non-Alcoholic Margarita Case of 24 with the Spritz and Margarita Variety Pack to decide which bulk option fits your next party or quiet night in.
Quick answer
Choose the Non-Alcoholic Margarita Case of 24 if you want one dependable drink for a crowd and value the lowest cost per can. Choose the Non-Alcoholic Spritz and Margarita Variety Pack if you want to offer two different cocktails without committing to 24 identical cans.
What you actually get in each pack
The Margarita Case of 24 is a single-flavor bulk buy: 24 ready-to-drink cans of Lyre's non-alcoholic margarita. The Spritz and Margarita Variety Pack is a curated selection that includes both spritz and margarita options, so guests can pick between two styles. Both are designed for easy serving, but only the case gives you enough of one drink to cover a large group without running out.
Cost per serving and party math
At the catalog price, the case of 24 works out to roughly $2.71 per can, while the 8-pack of margarita is about $2.76 per can. The variety pack sits at $23.03 for a mixed selection, so its per-drink value depends on how many cans are included—a detail not listed in the catalog facts. If your priority is the lowest known cost per serving for a margarita-only crowd, the case of 24 is the clearer bulk buy.
Flavor variety vs. single-flavor depth
A party where everyone drinks the same cocktail is simpler with the case of 24: no one has to choose, and you can chill the whole case at once. A mixed crowd, however, often appreciates the variety pack because it covers both a spritz-style aperitif and a margarita without buying two separate cases. The trade-off is that you cannot guarantee an equal number of each flavor, and you may run out of the more popular one first.
Occasions that change the answer
For a taco night, a birthday, or a backyard gathering where margaritas are the main event, the case of 24 keeps the host out of the kitchen and the drinks consistent. For a mixed holiday party, a tasting table, or a smaller gathering where guests have different preferences, the variety pack gives you more range with less commitment. If you are unsure, start with the variety pack, then buy the case of 24 once you know margarita is the crowd favorite.
Trade-offs at a glance
- Case of 24: best cost per serving: At $64.97 for 24 cans, the case is about $2.71 per can, the lowest known per-drink price among the margarita options here. Buy the case when margarita is the only drink you need.
- Variety pack: more range, less certainty: The Spritz and Margarita Variety Pack offers two cocktail styles, but the catalog does not list how many cans of each are included. Choose it for mixed crowds, not for guaranteed margarita volume.
- 8-pack: the low-commitment test: The 8-pack costs $22.07 and gives you eight margarita cans to try before scaling up to a case. Start here if you have never served Lyre's margarita to your guests.
Product facts
- Non-Alcoholic Margarita (Case of 24): Non-Alcoholic Margarita delivers the bold, zesty taste of a classic margarita without any alcohol; case includes 24 ready-to-drink cans. One flavor in bulk means consistent drinks and fewer decisions for a large group.
- Non-Alcoholic Spritz and Margarita (Variety Pack): Non-Alcoholic Spritz and Margarita Variety Pack brings together two classic cocktail experiences, crafted for bold flavor without alcohol. Two styles in one pack let guests choose, which suits mixed-preference crowds.
- Non-Alcoholic Margarita (8 Pack): Non-Alcoholic Margarita (8 Pack) contains 8 cans of non-alcoholic margarita for convenient enjoyment. A smaller margarita-only option if you want to test the flavor before committing to a case.
Which pack fits your plans?
Best for
- Hosting a party where margaritas are the main drink and you want the lowest cost per can
- Stocking a consistent single-flavor option for repeated gatherings
- Buying in bulk for a crowd without needing a second cocktail style
Not for
- Guests with mixed preferences who may want a spritz option
- Small households that would struggle to finish 24 cans before they go flat
- Shoppers who want to test the flavor first and may prefer the 8-pack
